Old Agreement Conditions Irrelevant

Inattention has caught out an employer who had assumed a key employment term had been ‘rolled over’ from an expired agreement into the new agreement. And despite evidence that the old agreement contained the missing terms, the Fair Work Commission was unmoved. The trouble started when the employer re-drafted the agreement from a PDF format […]

Devil (and the Dollars) in the Detail

Two cases decided within a week of each other highlight how important drafting of enterprise agreements is. Both cases involved argument about what the agreement clauses meant, and in both, the employer lost out, having to pay for lax drafting. The first involved an argument about Latin. The agreement used the term “i.e.” which of […]

Wrong Explanation of EBA’s Effect Kills Deal

When a large mining operator made a new agreement with a small number of employees, it focussed almost entirely on explaining to them the differences between the new deal and the existing agreement. So much so that in answer to the crucial question about the proposed agreement, “Are there any terms less beneficial to the […]

Sign Here or Else!

Once again the fine print around agreement-making has caused angst for an employer and employees because of a technicality in the approval process. And the Commissioner who had to deliver the bad news, expressed regret that she couldn’t waive the minor irregularity and approve the deal. The Fair Work Act, coupled with its regulations, requires […]

No employees working, but agreement still OK

The High Court has given the green light to an enterprise agreement even though the employees had not actually started at a new work site, after the company appealed a full federal court decision disallowing the agreement. The orthodox way to establish an agreement before opening the doors to trade, is to do an agreement […]

Non-permissible Claim Halts Protected Action Ballot

When a major union continued to pursue demands about restrictions on the use of contractors, it effectively ceased to bargain in good faith, the Fair Work Commission has found. This meant the FWC could not grant the union members a protected action ballot. The controversial claim being pursued was centred on imposing restrictions on the […]

Sacked Bargaining Reps Have Rights Too

When an employer found out that a union member had revoked his union’s right to be his bargaining representative, it assumed the union could have no further role in the process. But that turned out to be wrong, with a full bench of the FWC saying the union still had a right to be heard. […]

Show Us the Books

The Fair Work Commission has ordered an employer to produce books of account showing its financial status, in a long running bargaining dispute with several unions. Despite its protestations about the extent of the financial records and other material it has to produce, a full bench of the FWC has required the company to hand […]